MetaWin Output Feb 24, 2016 11:49 PM Data loaded from C:\Users\Eva\Desktop\MetaWin Humusveränderungen BDF.txt 14 rows X 30 columns The first row contained column headers ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:51 PM Data saved to C:\Users\Eva\Desktop\MetaWin Humusveränderungen BDF.txt ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:51 PM Calculation of Effect Sizes - ln Response Ratio Feb 24, 2016 11:52 PM Data saved to C:\Users\Eva\Desktop\MetaWin Humusveränderungen BDF.txt ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:52 PM Calculation of Effect Sizes - ln Response Ratio Feb 24, 2016 11:53 PM Data loaded from C:\Users\Eva\Desktop\MetaWin Humusveränderungen BDF.txt 14 rows X 29 columns The first row contained column headers ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:54 PM Calculation of Effect Sizes - ln Response Ratio Study Effect Variance ------------------------------ Study 1 0.0236 0.0036 Study 2 0.2604 0.0175 Study 3 -0.2546 0.0317 Study 4 -0.1404 0.0091 Study 5 0.1876 0.0070 Study 6 -0.6391 0.0871 Study 7 -0.4624 0.0082 Study 8 0.0977 0.0097 Study 9 -0.6669 0.0636 Study 10 -0.1283 0.0098 Study 11 -0.3060 0.0485 Study 12 -0.1229 0.0610 Study 13 -0.3416 0.1970 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:54 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0470 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 12.8694 12 0.37860 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1304 -0.2936 to 0.0329 -0.2788 to 0.0039 -0.2787 to 0.0062 E++ 0.8778 0.7456 to 1.0334 0.7567 to 1.0039 0.7568 to 1.0062 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2167 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.0863 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:54 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (Hoehe_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0191 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.0211 3.0000 6 0.0142 1.0000 5 0.0272 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 12.4439 0.00199 0.021 Within 10 9.1921 0.51398 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 21.6360 0.04181 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 -0.0623 1 -1.6539 to 1.5292 -0.2546 to 0.0236 -0.2546 to 0.0236 3.0000 6 0.0668 5 -0.1417 to 0.2752 -0.0838 to 0.1771 -0.1346 to 0.1707 1.0000 5 -0.3740 4 -0.6408 to -0.1073 -0.5726 to -0.2067 -0.5726 to -0.1952 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.9396 1 0.1913 to 4.6144 0.7753 to 1.0239 0.7753 to 1.0239 3.0000 6 1.0690 5 0.8679 to 1.3168 0.9196 to 1.1938 0.8740 to 1.1862 1.0000 5 0.6880 4 0.5269 to 0.8983 0.5640 to 0.8133 0.5640 to 0.8227 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 21.6360 12 0.04181 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1060 -0.2270 to 0.0150 -0.2687 to 0.0269 -0.2762 to 0.0237 E++ 0.8995 0.7969 to 1.0152 0.7644 to 1.0272 0.7587 to 1.0240 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.1382 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 3.2445 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (INSOLATION_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0643 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.0860 1.0000 5 0.0380 3.0000 4 0.0695 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 0.9048 0.63610 0.657 Within 10 9.5130 0.48420 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 10.4178 0.57936 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 -0.2439 3 -0.7395 to 0.2517 -0.4362 to -0.0055 -0.4362 to -0.0055 1.0000 5 -0.0484 4 -0.4264 to 0.3296 -0.2983 to 0.1535 -0.3064 to 0.1443 3.0000 4 -0.1521 3 -0.6224 to 0.3182 -0.4701 to 0.0999 -0.4701 to 0.0999 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.7836 3 0.4774 to 1.2862 0.6465 to 0.9945 0.6465 to 0.9945 1.0000 5 0.9528 4 0.6529 to 1.3905 0.7420 to 1.1659 0.7361 to 1.1552 3.0000 4 0.8589 3 0.5366 to 1.3746 0.6249 to 1.1050 0.6249 to 1.1050 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 10.4178 12 0.57936 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1393 -0.3228 to 0.0442 -0.3185 to 0.0040 -0.3219 to 0.0017 E++ 0.8700 0.7242 to 1.0452 0.7272 to 1.0040 0.7248 to 1.0017 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2535 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.9504 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MAT_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0505 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.0056 1.0000 3 0.0342 3.0000 6 0.0950 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 2.5864 0.27440 0.365 Within 10 9.6867 0.46840 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 12.2730 0.42401 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 -0.0512 3 -0.4560 to 0.3537 -0.1956 to 0.0587 -0.2432 to 0.0587 1.0000 3 0.0487 2 -0.7686 to 0.8660 -0.3416 to 0.2604 -0.3416 to 0.2604 3.0000 6 -0.2588 5 -0.5472 to 0.0296 -0.5093 to -0.0358 -0.4887 to -0.0167 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.9501 3 0.6338 to 1.4243 0.8224 to 1.0604 0.7841 to 1.0604 1.0000 3 1.0499 2 0.4637 to 2.3773 0.7106 to 1.2975 0.7106 to 1.2975 3.0000 6 0.7720 5 0.5786 to 1.0300 0.6009 to 0.9648 0.6134 to 0.9834 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 12.2730 12 0.42401 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1324 -0.3000 to 0.0352 -0.2904 to 0.0040 -0.2940 to 0.0042 E++ 0.8760 0.7408 to 1.0358 0.7480 to 1.0041 0.7453 to 1.0042 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2247 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.2740 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MST_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0372 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.0158 1.0000 3 0.0342 3.0000 6 0.0626 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 4.1948 0.12278 0.223 Within 10 10.7030 0.38112 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 14.8978 0.24707 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 -0.0184 3 -0.3741 to 0.3373 -0.1912 to 0.1152 -0.1912 to 0.1152 1.0000 3 0.0627 2 -0.6895 to 0.8149 -0.3416 to 0.1975 -0.2227 to 0.2604 3.0000 6 -0.2730 5 -0.5335 to -0.0125 -0.5159 to -0.0708 -0.5159 to -0.0708 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.9818 3 0.6879 to 1.4011 0.8259 to 1.1221 0.8259 to 1.1221 1.0000 3 1.0647 2 0.5018 to 2.2590 0.7106 to 1.2183 0.8004 to 1.2975 3.0000 6 0.7611 5 0.5865 to 0.9876 0.5969 to 0.9317 0.5969 to 0.9317 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 14.8978 12 0.24707 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1237 -0.2740 to 0.0266 -0.2956 to 0.0106 -0.2882 to 0.0130 E++ 0.8836 0.7603 to 1.0269 0.7441 to 1.0107 0.7496 to 1.0131 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.1930 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 4.5293 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MWT_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0527 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 3 0.0028 1.0000 4 0.0578 3.0000 6 0.0950 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 2.3809 0.30409 0.389 Within 10 9.5491 0.48091 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 11.9299 0.45132 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 3 -0.0014 2 -0.6112 to 0.6084 -0.1283 to 0.0977 -0.1283 to 0.0977 1.0000 4 -0.0477 3 -0.5714 to 0.4760 -0.3163 to 0.1951 -0.3163 to 0.2089 3.0000 6 -0.2604 5 -0.5534 to 0.0326 -0.5223 to -0.0319 -0.5217 to -0.0273 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 3 0.9986 2 0.5427 to 1.8375 0.8796 to 1.1026 0.8796 to 1.1026 1.0000 4 0.9534 3 0.5647 to 1.6095 0.7288 to 1.2154 0.7288 to 1.2323 3.0000 6 0.7707 5 0.5750 to 1.0331 0.5932 to 0.9686 0.5935 to 0.9731 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 11.9299 12 0.45132 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1336 -0.3039 to 0.0366 -0.2941 to -0.0047 -0.2892 to -0.0017 E++ 0.8749 0.7379 to 1.0373 0.7452 to 0.9953 0.7489 to 0.9983 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2295 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.3879 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MAP_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0269 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 3.0000 5 0.0065 1.0000 6 0.0443 2.0000 2 -0.0124 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 7.9574 0.01871 0.076 Within 10 10.0629 0.43499 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 18.0203 0.11508 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 5 0.0920 4 -0.1848 to 0.3687 -0.0787 to 0.2004 -0.0787 to 0.2004 1.0000 6 -0.2132 5 -0.4314 to 0.0049 -0.4070 to -0.0504 -0.4088 to -0.0526 2.0000 2 -0.4386 1 -3.1457 to 2.2686 -0.6391 to -0.3060 -0.6391 to -0.3060 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 5 1.0963 4 0.8313 to 1.4459 0.9243 to 1.2219 0.9243 to 1.2219 1.0000 6 0.8080 5 0.6496 to 1.0049 0.6657 to 0.9508 0.6644 to 0.9488 2.0000 2 0.6449 1 0.0430 to 9.6654 0.5278 to 0.7364 0.5278 to 0.7364 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 18.0203 12 0.11508 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1148 -0.2495 to 0.0199 -0.2676 to 0.0214 -0.2742 to 0.0191 E++ 0.8916 0.7792 to 1.0201 0.7652 to 1.0216 0.7602 to 1.0193 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.1641 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 3.8514 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (SUBSTR_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0162 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.0138 3.0000 5 0.0292 2.0000 2 -0.1051 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 13.2104 0.00135 0.014 Within 10 10.2448 0.41929 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 23.4552 0.02410 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.0447 5 -0.1278 to 0.2171 -0.0985 to 0.1560 -0.0865 to 0.1598 3.0000 5 -0.3685 4 -0.6251 to -0.1120 -0.5668 to -0.1969 -0.5624 to -0.1830 2.0000 2 -0.1811 1 -3.2070 to 2.8449 -0.3416 to -0.1229 -0.3416 to -0.1229 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 1.0457 5 0.8801 to 1.2425 0.9062 to 1.1688 0.9171 to 1.1732 3.0000 5 0.6918 4 0.5352 to 0.8941 0.5674 to 0.8213 0.5698 to 0.8328 2.0000 2 0.8344 1 0.0405 to 17.1998 0.7106 to 0.8844 0.7106 to 0.8844 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 23.4552 12 0.02410 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1021 -0.2174 to 0.0133 -0.2628 to 0.0246 -0.2539 to 0.0292 E++ 0.9030 0.8046 to 1.0133 0.7689 to 1.0249 0.7758 to 1.0297 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.1273 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 2.9888 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (BODEN_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0460 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.0033 2.0000 5 0.0907 3.0000 5 0.0041 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 4.8495 0.08850 0.182 Within 10 8.1963 0.60967 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 13.0457 0.36573 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.1176 2 -0.4687 to 0.7038 0.0236 to 0.2014 0.0236 to 0.2604 2.0000 5 -0.2058 4 -0.5246 to 0.1129 -0.4620 to 0.0399 -0.4514 to 0.0494 3.0000 5 -0.2775 4 -0.6659 to 0.1109 -0.5096 to -0.1415 -0.5356 to -0.1446 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 1.1247 2 0.6258 to 2.0214 1.0239 to 1.2231 1.0239 to 1.2975 2.0000 5 0.8140 4 0.5918 to 1.1195 0.6300 to 1.0407 0.6368 to 1.0507 3.0000 5 0.7577 4 0.5138 to 1.1173 0.6007 to 0.8680 0.5853 to 0.8654 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 13.0457 12 0.36573 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1298 -0.2917 to 0.0322 -0.2880 to 0.0068 -0.2883 to 0.0076 E++ 0.8783 0.7470 to 1.0328 0.7498 to 1.0068 0.7496 to 1.0076 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2144 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.0331 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:55 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT88-12_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Excluded Studies: Study 12 Excluded Groups from "DEL_MAT88-12_KL": 3.0000 Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0591 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.0285 2.0000 6 0.0808 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 1 0.1075 0.74296 0.769 Within 10 10.9271 0.36323 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 11 11.0346 0.44037 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 -0.1072 5 -0.4293 to 0.2149 -0.3548 to 0.0839 -0.3439 to 0.0937 2.0000 6 -0.1626 5 -0.4533 to 0.1281 -0.3987 to 0.0507 -0.3936 to 0.0549 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.8983 5 0.6509 to 1.2397 0.7013 to 1.0875 0.7090 to 1.0982 2.0000 6 0.8499 5 0.6356 to 1.1367 0.6712 to 1.0520 0.6746 to 1.0564 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 11.0346 11 0.44037 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1377 -0.3225 to 0.0470 -0.3036 to 0.0159 -0.3061 to 0.0151 E++ 0.8713 0.7243 to 1.0482 0.7381 to 1.0161 0.7363 to 1.0152 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2431 Mean Study Variance = 0.0411 Ratio = 5.9209 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:56 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT81-10_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0527 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 6 0.0545 1.0000 5 0.0542 3.0000 2 -0.1051 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 0.8661 0.64853 0.694 Within 10 11.0630 0.35263 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 11.9291 0.45139 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 6 -0.1939 5 -0.4732 to 0.0854 -0.4306 to -0.0238 -0.4386 to -0.0237 1.0000 5 -0.0454 4 -0.3866 to 0.2959 -0.3220 to 0.1578 -0.3220 to 0.1578 3.0000 2 -0.1913 1 -3.7434 to 3.3607 -0.3416 to -0.1229 -0.3416 to -0.1229 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 6 0.8237 5 0.6230 to 1.0891 0.6501 to 0.9765 0.6449 to 0.9766 1.0000 5 0.9556 4 0.6793 to 1.3443 0.7247 to 1.1709 0.7247 to 1.1709 3.0000 2 0.8259 1 0.0237 to 28.8098 0.7106 to 0.8844 0.7106 to 0.8844 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 11.9291 12 0.45139 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1336 -0.3039 to 0.0366 -0.2954 to 0.0024 -0.2946 to 0.0046 E++ 0.8749 0.7379 to 1.0373 0.7443 to 1.0024 0.7448 to 1.0046 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2296 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.3881 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:56 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DELTA_MAP88-12_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0537 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 3.0000 8 0.0585 1.0000 3 0.0342 2.0000 2 -0.0151 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 1.0743 0.58440 0.630 Within 10 10.7033 0.38109 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 11.7777 0.46370 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 8 -0.1620 7 -0.3886 to 0.0645 -0.3759 to 0.0153 -0.3753 to 0.0191 1.0000 3 0.0458 2 -0.7862 to 0.8778 -0.3416 to 0.2604 -0.3416 to 0.2604 2.0000 2 -0.2035 1 -2.7101 to 2.3031 -0.3060 to -0.1404 -0.3060 to -0.1404 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 8 0.8504 7 0.6780 to 1.0667 0.6867 to 1.0154 0.6871 to 1.0193 1.0000 3 1.0469 2 0.4556 to 2.4055 0.7106 to 1.2975 0.7106 to 1.2975 2.0000 2 0.8159 1 0.0665 to 10.0054 0.7364 to 0.8690 0.7364 to 0.8690 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 11.7777 12 0.46370 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1342 -0.3057 to 0.0373 -0.2883 to -0.0031 -0.2848 to 0.0002 E++ 0.8744 0.7366 to 1.0380 0.7496 to 0.9969 0.7522 to 1.0002 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2318 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 5.4399 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:56 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DELTA_MAP81-10_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0411 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.0195 2.0000 3 0.0169 3.0000 4 0.1112 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 2.8816 0.23674 0.291 Within 10 11.1314 0.34737 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 12 14.0129 0.29988 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 0.0059 5 -0.2660 to 0.2778 -0.1996 to 0.1543 -0.1986 to 0.1543 2.0000 3 -0.2380 2 -0.8520 to 0.3761 -0.6669 to -0.1283 -0.6669 to -0.1323 3.0000 4 -0.2372 3 -0.6566 to 0.1823 -0.5114 to 0.0244 -0.5114 to 0.0663 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 6 1.0059 5 0.7664 to 1.3202 0.8191 to 1.1669 0.8199 to 1.1669 2.0000 3 0.7882 2 0.4266 to 1.4565 0.5133 to 0.8796 0.5133 to 0.8760 3.0000 4 0.7889 3 0.5186 to 1.2000 0.5996 to 1.0247 0.5996 to 1.0685 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 14.0129 12 0.29988 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1265 -0.2822 to 0.0291 -0.2986 to 0.0126 -0.3092 to 0.0090 E++ 0.8811 0.7542 to 1.0295 0.7419 to 1.0127 0.7340 to 1.0090 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2027 Mean Study Variance = 0.0426 Ratio = 4.7584 -------------------------------------------------------------