Feb 24, 2016 11:15 PM Calculation of Effect Sizes - ln Response Ratio Study Effect Variance ------------------------------ Study 1 -0.4527 0.0099 Study 2 -0.2516 0.0270 Study 3 -0.0140 0.0123 Study 4 -0.0239 0.0097 Study 5 -0.3749 0.0233 Study 6 -0.2406 0.0269 Study 7 0.2148 0.0131 Study 8 0.5138 0.0036 Study 9 -0.1840 0.0078 Study 10 -0.3363 0.0107 Study 11 -0.7310 0.0264 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:15 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1517 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.9215 10 0.73283 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- E++ -0.1615 -0.4359 to 0.1129 -0.3424 to 0.0346 -0.3213 to 0.0460 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3895 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 25.1125 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:16 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1517 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.9215 10 0.73283 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1615 -0.4359 to 0.1129 -0.3459 to 0.0390 -0.3462 to 0.0382 E++ 0.8509 0.6467 to 1.1195 0.7076 to 1.0397 0.7073 to 1.0389 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3895 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 25.1125 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:16 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (Hoehe_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1632 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.0518 2.0000 6 0.2083 3.0000 2 0.1400 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 0.3777 0.82789 0.798 Within 8 6.0910 0.63704 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 6.4688 0.77446 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 -0.2815 2 -1.3276 to 0.7646 -0.4527 to -0.0239 -0.4527 to -0.1351 2.0000 6 -0.1356 5 -0.5808 to 0.3096 -0.4296 to 0.1645 -0.4287 to 0.1666 3.0000 2 -0.0626 1 -3.8222 to 3.6970 -0.3363 to 0.2148 -0.3363 to 0.2148 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.7546 2 0.2651 to 2.1480 0.6359 to 0.9763 0.6359 to 0.8736 2.0000 6 0.8732 5 0.5595 to 1.3629 0.6508 to 1.1788 0.6514 to 1.1813 3.0000 2 0.9393 1 0.0219 to 40.3268 0.7144 to 1.2396 0.7144 to 1.2396 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.4688 10 0.77446 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1621 -0.4458 to 0.1216 -0.3570 to 0.0321 -0.3583 to 0.0334 E++ 0.8504 0.6403 to 1.1293 0.6997 to 1.0327 0.6989 to 1.0340 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.4040 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 26.0447 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:17 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (INSOLATION_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0953 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 2 -0.0136 1.0000 4 0.0616 3.0000 5 0.1259 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 4.6090 0.09981 0.133 Within 8 5.9569 0.65206 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 10.5659 0.39232 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 -0.4161 1 -3.4159 to 2.5837 -0.4527 to -0.3749 -0.4527 to -0.3749 1.0000 4 -0.3243 3 -0.8595 to 0.2109 -0.6167 to -0.1015 -0.6116 to -0.1015 3.0000 5 0.0708 4 -0.3362 to 0.4778 -0.1600 to 0.3267 -0.1429 to 0.3410 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.6596 1 0.0328 to 13.2459 0.6359 to 0.6874 0.6359 to 0.6874 1.0000 4 0.7230 3 0.4234 to 1.2348 0.5397 to 0.9035 0.5425 to 0.9035 3.0000 5 1.0734 4 0.7145 to 1.6125 0.8521 to 1.3864 0.8668 to 1.4064 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 10.5659 10 0.39232 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1566 -0.3796 to 0.0663 -0.3491 to 0.0358 -0.3429 to 0.0439 E++ 0.8550 0.6841 to 1.0686 0.7053 to 1.0364 0.7097 to 1.0448 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3087 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 19.8982 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:17 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MAT_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1486 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 5 0.2046 2.0000 4 0.0378 3.0000 2 0.0051 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 1.8523 0.39607 0.361 Within 8 5.2036 0.73561 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 7.0559 0.72016 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 5 -0.0111 4 -0.5054 to 0.4832 -0.3192 to 0.2938 -0.3213 to 0.2938 2.0000 4 -0.3796 3 -1.0344 to 0.2752 -0.6115 to -0.2158 -0.6408 to -0.2332 3.0000 2 -0.1267 1 -3.7929 to 3.5395 -0.2406 to -0.0239 -0.2406 to -0.0239 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 5 0.9890 4 0.6033 to 1.6213 0.7267 to 1.3415 0.7252 to 1.3415 2.0000 4 0.6841 3 0.3554 to 1.3168 0.5426 to 0.8059 0.5269 to 0.7920 3.0000 2 0.8810 1 0.0225 to 34.4509 0.7862 to 0.9763 0.7862 to 0.9763 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 7.0559 10 0.72016 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1613 -0.4331 to 0.1105 -0.3485 to 0.0246 -0.3497 to 0.0263 E++ 0.8510 0.6485 to 1.1168 0.7057 to 1.0249 0.7049 to 1.0267 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3855 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 24.8529 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:17 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MST_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1486 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 5 0.2046 2.0000 4 0.0378 3.0000 2 0.0051 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 1.8523 0.39607 0.392 Within 8 5.2036 0.73561 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 7.0559 0.72016 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 5 -0.0111 4 -0.5054 to 0.4832 -0.3192 to 0.2670 -0.3192 to 0.2904 2.0000 4 -0.3796 3 -1.0344 to 0.2752 -0.6115 to -0.1995 -0.6408 to -0.2284 3.0000 2 -0.1267 1 -3.7929 to 3.5395 -0.2406 to -0.0239 -0.2406 to -0.0239 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 5 0.9890 4 0.6033 to 1.6213 0.7267 to 1.3061 0.7267 to 1.3370 2.0000 4 0.6841 3 0.3554 to 1.3168 0.5426 to 0.8192 0.5269 to 0.7958 3.0000 2 0.8810 1 0.0225 to 34.4509 0.7862 to 0.9763 0.7862 to 0.9763 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 7.0559 10 0.72016 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1613 -0.4331 to 0.1105 -0.3483 to 0.0378 -0.3461 to 0.0471 E++ 0.8510 0.6485 to 1.1168 0.7059 to 1.0385 0.7074 to 1.0483 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3855 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 24.8529 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:17 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MWT_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1128 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.0123 1.0000 5 0.1736 3.0000 2 -0.0110 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 3.8736 0.14416 0.185 Within 8 5.2074 0.73520 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 9.0810 0.52443 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 -0.4496 3 -1.0322 to 0.1329 -0.6405 to -0.2989 -0.6405 to -0.2989 1.0000 5 0.0018 4 -0.4368 to 0.4403 -0.2725 to 0.3195 -0.2725 to 0.3195 3.0000 2 -0.0190 1 -3.1800 to 3.1420 -0.0239 to -0.0140 -0.0239 to -0.0140 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 4 0.6379 3 0.3562 to 1.1422 0.5270 to 0.7416 0.5270 to 0.7416 1.0000 5 1.0018 4 0.6461 to 1.5532 0.7615 to 1.3764 0.7615 to 1.3764 3.0000 2 0.9812 1 0.0416 to 23.1508 0.9763 to 0.9861 0.9763 to 0.9861 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 9.0810 10 0.52443 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1586 -0.3987 to 0.0815 -0.3559 to 0.0524 -0.3537 to 0.0573 E++ 0.8533 0.6712 to 1.0849 0.7006 to 1.0538 0.7021 to 1.0590 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3358 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 21.6505 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:19 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT88-12_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1519 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.4603 3.0000 7 0.0570 1.0000 2 0.0405 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 0.6520 0.72181 0.680 Within 8 6.2636 0.61774 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 6.9156 0.73339 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.0402 1 -3.5377 to 3.6180 -0.4527 to 0.5138 -0.4527 to 0.5138 3.0000 7 -0.2192 6 -0.6013 to 0.1629 -0.4174 to -0.0260 -0.4450 to -0.0326 1.0000 2 -0.1759 1 -3.8073 to 3.4555 -0.3363 to -0.0140 -0.3363 to -0.0140 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 1.0410 1 0.0291 to 37.2645 0.6359 to 1.6716 0.6359 to 1.6716 3.0000 7 0.8032 6 0.5481 to 1.1769 0.6588 to 0.9744 0.6408 to 0.9679 1.0000 2 0.8387 1 0.0222 to 31.6754 0.7144 to 0.9861 0.7144 to 0.9861 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.9156 10 0.73339 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1615 -0.4360 to 0.1130 -0.3482 to 0.0338 -0.3370 to 0.0493 E++ 0.8509 0.6466 to 1.1197 0.7060 to 1.0344 0.7139 to 1.0506 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3897 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 25.1242 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:19 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT81-10_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0755 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.1069 3.0000 6 0.0334 2.0000 2 0.1313 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 5.4007 0.06718 0.108 Within 8 7.5558 0.47802 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 12.9565 0.22611 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 -0.1959 2 -0.9275 to 0.5358 -0.4527 to 0.2148 -0.4141 to 0.2148 3.0000 6 -0.2890 5 -0.6124 to 0.0344 -0.4895 to -0.1456 -0.5098 to -0.1460 2.0000 2 0.2636 1 -2.3288 to 2.8560 -0.0140 to 0.5138 -0.0140 to 0.5138 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.8221 2 0.3955 to 1.7089 0.6359 to 1.2396 0.6609 to 1.2396 3.0000 6 0.7490 5 0.5421 to 1.0350 0.6129 to 0.8645 0.6006 to 0.8641 2.0000 2 1.3016 1 0.0974 to 17.3919 0.9861 to 1.6716 0.9861 to 1.6716 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 12.9565 10 0.22611 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1535 -0.3554 to 0.0484 -0.3514 to 0.0422 -0.3341 to 0.0595 E++ 0.8577 0.7009 to 1.0496 0.7037 to 1.0431 0.7160 to 1.0613 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2749 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 17.7187 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:19 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (MAP_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1061 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 2 0.0821 2.0000 6 0.0333 3.0000 3 0.2018 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 3.2457 0.19733 0.214 Within 8 6.3534 0.60772 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 9.5991 0.47634 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 2 -0.2382 1 -3.2967 to 2.8204 -0.4527 to -0.0239 -0.4527 to -0.0239 2.0000 6 -0.2913 5 -0.6640 to 0.0815 -0.4779 to -0.1369 -0.4707 to -0.1358 3.0000 3 0.1384 2 -0.7042 to 0.9809 -0.3363 to 0.5138 -0.3363 to 0.4196 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 2 0.7881 1 0.0370 to 16.7833 0.6359 to 0.9763 0.6359 to 0.9763 2.0000 6 0.7473 5 0.5148 to 1.0849 0.6201 to 0.8721 0.6246 to 0.8730 3.0000 3 1.1484 2 0.4945 to 2.6670 0.7144 to 1.6716 0.7144 to 1.5213 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 9.5991 10 0.47634 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1579 -0.3916 to 0.0758 -0.3440 to 0.0384 -0.3342 to 0.0510 E++ 0.8539 0.6760 to 1.0787 0.7089 to 1.0391 0.7159 to 1.0524 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3257 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 20.9946 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (SUBSTR_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Excluded Studies: Study 1 Excluded Groups from "SUBSTR_KL": 3.0000 Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1223 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 7 0.0570 1.0000 3 0.2218 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 1 1.2356 0.26632 0.237 Within 8 6.4870 0.59285 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 9 7.7226 0.56232 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 7 -0.2175 6 -0.5648 to 0.1298 -0.4342 to -0.0328 -0.4424 to -0.0387 1.0000 3 0.0633 2 -0.8358 to 0.9624 -0.3363 to 0.5138 -0.2297 to 0.5138 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 7 0.8045 6 0.5685 to 1.1385 0.6478 to 0.9678 0.6425 to 0.9620 1.0000 3 1.0653 2 0.4335 to 2.6180 0.7144 to 1.6716 0.7948 to 1.6716 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 7.7226 9 0.56232 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1289 -0.3945 to 0.1367 -0.3215 to 0.0727 -0.3190 to 0.0756 E++ 0.8791 0.6740 to 1.1465 0.7251 to 1.0754 0.7269 to 1.0785 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3496 Mean Study Variance = 0.0161 Ratio = 21.7536 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (BODEN_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Excluded Studies: Study 10 Excluded Groups from "BODEN_KL": 1.0000 Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0535 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 3.0000 6 0.0198 2.0000 4 0.0822 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 1 10.8655 0.00098 0.003 Within 8 5.8833 0.66030 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 9 16.7488 0.05280 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 6 -0.3672 5 -0.6502 to -0.0842 -0.5231 to -0.2402 -0.5408 to -0.2427 2.0000 4 0.1830 3 -0.2162 to 0.5823 -0.0190 to 0.3953 -0.0190 to 0.3953 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3.0000 6 0.6927 5 0.5219 to 0.9193 0.5927 to 0.7865 0.5823 to 0.7845 2.0000 4 1.2009 3 0.8056 to 1.7902 0.9811 to 1.4849 0.9811 to 1.4849 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 16.7488 9 0.05280 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1278 -0.3150 to 0.0595 -0.3378 to 0.0814 -0.3317 to 0.0874 E++ 0.8801 0.7298 to 1.0613 0.7134 to 1.0848 0.7177 to 1.0913 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2313 Mean Study Variance = 0.0160 Ratio = 14.4645 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT88-12_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1519 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.4603 3.0000 7 0.0570 1.0000 2 0.0405 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 0.6520 0.72181 0.662 Within 8 6.2636 0.61774 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 6.9156 0.73339 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 0.0402 1 -3.5377 to 3.6180 -0.4527 to 0.5138 -0.4527 to 0.5138 3.0000 7 -0.2192 6 -0.6013 to 0.1629 -0.4178 to -0.0372 -0.4143 to -0.0316 1.0000 2 -0.1759 1 -3.8073 to 3.4555 -0.3363 to -0.0140 -0.3363 to -0.0140 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 2 1.0410 1 0.0291 to 37.2645 0.6359 to 1.6716 0.6359 to 1.6716 3.0000 7 0.8032 6 0.5481 to 1.1769 0.6585 to 0.9635 0.6608 to 0.9689 1.0000 2 0.8387 1 0.0222 to 31.6754 0.7144 to 0.9861 0.7144 to 0.9861 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.9156 10 0.73339 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1615 -0.4360 to 0.1130 -0.3533 to 0.0311 -0.3484 to 0.0380 E++ 0.8509 0.6466 to 1.1197 0.7024 to 1.0316 0.7058 to 1.0387 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3897 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 25.1242 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DEL_MAT81-10_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.0755 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.1069 3.0000 6 0.0334 2.0000 2 0.1313 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ----------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 5.4007 0.06718 0.116 Within 8 7.5558 0.47802 ----------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 12.9565 0.22611 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 -0.1959 2 -0.9275 to 0.5358 -0.4527 to 0.2148 -0.4141 to 0.2148 3.0000 6 -0.2890 5 -0.6124 to 0.0344 -0.4680 to -0.1416 -0.4883 to -0.1460 2.0000 2 0.2636 1 -2.3288 to 2.8560 -0.0140 to 0.5138 -0.0140 to 0.5138 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.0000 3 0.8221 2 0.3955 to 1.7089 0.6359 to 1.2396 0.6609 to 1.2396 3.0000 6 0.7490 5 0.5421 to 1.0350 0.6263 to 0.8679 0.6137 to 0.8641 2.0000 2 1.3016 1 0.0974 to 17.3919 0.9861 to 1.6716 0.9861 to 1.6716 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ----------------------------------------- Qtotal 12.9565 10 0.22611 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1535 -0.3554 to 0.0484 -0.3476 to 0.0579 -0.3324 to 0.0701 E++ 0.8577 0.7009 to 1.0496 0.7064 to 1.0596 0.7172 to 1.0726 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.2749 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 17.7187 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DELTA_MAP88-12_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1092 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 6 0.0388 1.0000 5 0.1715 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 1 2.2728 0.13166 0.134 Within 9 7.0776 0.62904 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 9.3504 0.49920 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 6 -0.3075 5 -0.6808 to 0.0658 -0.4970 to -0.1466 -0.5023 to -0.1474 1.0000 5 0.0137 4 -0.4191 to 0.4464 -0.2909 to 0.2956 -0.2845 to 0.2975 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 6 0.7353 5 0.5062 to 1.0680 0.6083 to 0.8637 0.6052 to 0.8630 1.0000 5 1.0138 4 0.6576 to 1.5627 0.7476 to 1.3439 0.7524 to 1.3465 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 9.3504 10 0.49920 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1583 -0.3950 to 0.0785 -0.3380 to 0.0391 -0.3276 to 0.0517 E++ 0.8536 0.6737 to 1.0816 0.7132 to 1.0399 0.7206 to 1.0530 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3305 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 21.3028 ------------------------------------------------------------- Feb 24, 2016 11:20 PM Meta-Analysis Results Effect Size from column "lnR" Variance from column "Var(lnR)" Random effects model with a grouping variable (DELTA_MAP81-10_KL) Resampling tests generated from 999 iterations Estimate of pooled variance: 0.1521 CATEGORICAL RESULTS --Heterogeneity-- Class #Studies PooledVar ----------------------------- 2.0000 5 0.2046 3.0000 4 0.0385 1.0000 2 0.0451 Model df Q Prob(Chi-Square) Prob(Rand) ---------------------------------------------------------- Between 2 1.5033 0.47159 0.453 Within 8 5.4038 0.71367 ---------------------------------------------------------- Total 10 6.9071 0.73418 --Mean Effect Sizes-- Class #Studies lnE+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 5 -0.0112 4 -0.5108 to 0.4885 -0.3192 to 0.3095 -0.2978 to 0.3266 3.0000 4 -0.3472 3 -1.0103 to 0.3160 -0.6087 to -0.1970 -0.6087 to -0.1995 1.0000 2 -0.1924 1 -3.8787 to 3.4940 -0.3749 to -0.0239 -0.3749 to -0.0239 Class #Studies E+ df 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0000 5 0.9889 4 0.6000 to 1.6299 0.7267 to 1.3628 0.7424 to 1.3862 3.0000 4 0.7067 3 0.3641 to 1.3716 0.5441 to 0.8212 0.5441 to 0.8191 1.0000 2 0.8250 1 0.0207 to 32.9174 0.6874 to 0.9763 0.6874 to 0.9763 SUMMARY RESULTS Heterogeneity df Prob(Chi-Square) ---------------------------------------- Qtotal 6.9071 10 0.73418 Mean Effect Size 95% CI Bootstrap CI Bias CI ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- lnE++ -0.1615 -0.4362 to 0.1132 -0.3553 to 0.0265 -0.3543 to 0.0317 E++ 0.8509 0.6465 to 1.1198 0.7009 to 1.0269 0.7017 to 1.0322 Sqrt Pooled Variance = 0.3900 Mean Study Variance = 0.0155 Ratio = 25.1408 -------------------------------------------------------------